An Essay of Mental Health and Living Consciously by James Bonner

On Navigating Our Social Abyss

The illiterate of the 21st century will not be those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn, and relearn.” ~ Alvin Toffler.

 

I watch the woman ahead of me in line at the grocery store, her cart containing only a gallon of milk and a loaf of bread, while mine overflows with the week’s necessities. Something flickers across my consciousness—the impulse to let her go first, simple as breathing. But then the calculus begins: I’m already late, she’s probably fine waiting, maybe she’s one of those people who would be offended by the gesture. The moment passes. The impulse dies. And I’m left standing there, complicit in the small erosion of human decency that happens a thousand times a day, in a thousand checkout lines, across a thousand cities where people like me choose convenience over connection.

This is how kindness dies. It’s not in dramatic acts of cruelty, but in the accumulation of rationalized indifference. We want to be good. The desire lives so close to the surface of our consciousness that we can feel it stirring whenever opportunity presents itself. We want to hold doors open with genuine warmth, to chat with waiters in the same way we do friends we haven’t seen in years, to offer help to strangers struggling with heavy bags or confusing directions. Compassion is our factory setting, the default program running beneath the layers of learned cynicism and protective detachment.

But somewhere between impulse and action, we’ve developed an elaborate internal bureaucracy designed to talk us out of our better angels. We’re tired, always tired in this culture that mistakes exhaustion for importance. We’re busy, perpetually busy in ways that feel urgent but rarely matter. We’re suspiciously trained by a media landscape that profits from our distrust to see potential threats in every unfamiliar face. “My life is hard enough,” we whisper to ourselves, as if kindness were a finite resource we might somehow deplete through overuse.

This resistance to our own compassionate instincts isn’t natural; it’s learned behavior, carefully cultivated by a society that rewards performance over presence, accumulation over connection. What feels innate is actually the scar tissue formed over years of small betrayals, moments when we choose safety over vulnerability, efficiency over humanity. Our subconscious minds, those ancient repositories of pattern and precedent, have been saturated with messages of scarcity and threat until even the simplest gestures of human warmth feel like dangerous luxuries we can’t afford.

The result is a culture drowning in its own resentment, where our unconscious practices pull us toward behaviors that contradict our conscious values. We become merchants of the very inhumanity we claim to despise, crafting elaborate justifications for our cruelties while remaining blind to the hypocrisies that define our daily existence. We condemn bias while nurturing our own prejudices, demand empathy while withholding it from those whose pain doesn’t match our preferred narratives.

Real progress, the kind that actually changes hearts rather than simply rearranging surface behaviors, requires something most of us find terrifying: genuine consent. It cannot be coerced through shame or demanded through force. Progress without consent becomes violence, however well-intentioned, and if we’re honest with ourselves, we all carry wounds that have calcified into defensive patterns. The irony is that empathy is hardwired into our neural architecture. When we witness another person’s suffering, our brains quite literally cannot distinguish their pain from our own. However, accessing this natural capacity requires vulnerability, and vulnerability has been rebranded as weakness in a culture that mistakes armor for strength.

We suppress our sensitivity, laugh at others’ pain, and create distance where connection might heal. We avoid the very openness that would allow us to see clearly because being seen clearly feels too dangerous. When we suppress our essential humanity, even the smallest interactions become opportunities for unconscious violence. The door we don’t hold, the smile we withhold, the patience we refuse, these moments accumulate like sediment, gradually burying the person we intended to become under layers of defended indifference.

The division consuming our culture runs deeper than politics or ideology. It’s rooted in unconscious living, in our collective refusal to examine the internal landscape from which our external behaviors emerge. Conscious living requires something most people find unbearable: placing ourselves at the center of the problem rather than the solution. It demands that we consider the possibility that we might be contributing to the very dynamics we claim to oppose.

This self-examination requires sacrificing our biases. Those comfortable certainties that allow us to process complex realities through simple filters. We must learn to understand ideas objectively before relating to them subjectively, but most of us skip this crucial step. Instead, we encounter perspectives that challenge our worldview and dump everything unresolved onto them—decades of accumulated resentment, frustration, fear, and unprocessed pain—until the original idea disappears beneath the weight of our projections.

We’ve become so identified with conflict that peace feels like erasure. Our identities depend on having enemies to define ourselves against, problems to solve, and battles to fight. Even when victories are won, we keep fighting because the alternative—the vulnerable work of building something new—requires skills we’ve never developed and courage we’re not sure we possess.

The ripple effects of our actions extend far beyond the visible impacts we typically consider. While we may notice how our behavior affects others, we rarely examine the inner ripples—the way each choice shapes our habits, routines, addictions, and character. These invisible consequences accumulate over time, gradually molding us into people we might not recognize if we met ourselves honestly.

I’ve carried unhappiness for so long that imagining myself without it feels like imagining a stranger. People in my life have grown accustomed to my particular brand of melancholy. I’ve built my traumas into my personality until they feel like essential characteristics rather than temporary conditions. The idea of happiness seems not just unfamiliar but somehow unsafe. As if joy might expose vulnerabilities I’ve spent years learning to protect.

The strange truth is that often the only thing standing between us and contentment is the decision to choose it; after years of anxiety, resentment, and doubt, what would it actually look like to simply opt for joy? I’ve projected my pain into every relationship, every interaction, every interpretation of events. But becoming aware of this pattern creates a starting point for something different.

Most people, I’ve realized, don’t carry visions of how things could be; they’re focused, sometimes dangerously, on how things are. Even those working for change often harbor so much resentment that they struggle to recognize progress when it occurs. They keep fighting after battles are won because change feels uncomfortable, and discomfort breeds resistance. Conflict becomes addictive; we mistake the adrenaline of opposition for the energy of purpose.

Not everyone resists change because they’re committed to tradition; some resist because transformation is genuinely difficult, and we all move at different speeds through the landscape of growth. If we can’t accept this basic truth about human nature, we’ll exhaust ourselves trying to force others to match our pace rather than doing the patient work of modeling the changes we want to see.

The indifference I observe in both me and in others remains the most puzzling aspect of our current moment. We excuse our own failures by pointing to worse examples: “Smith doesn’t recycle, why should I? Smith is careless, why shouldn’t I be?” This isn’t political positioning. It’s behavioral dissonance that cripples our capacity for genuine improvement. We claim to be tolerant, but we practice tolerance selectively. We champion truth while accepting only versions that confirm our existing beliefs. We consume what we know is poisonous because we’ve grown tired of caring about ourselves.

We’ve somehow convinced ourselves that what works for us must be universal, that our personal preferences carry moral weight. But if living your best life requires closing your mind, hardening your heart, and elevating yourself through the diminishment of others, then perhaps we’re not actually living our best lives at all. We’re handling small things poorly and expecting large things to resolve themselves, but growth doesn’t work that way.

The work required isn’t punishment; it’s the process through which we create anything meaningful. Yet we’ve dismissed effort as somehow inhumane, as if struggle were an optional feature of human existence rather than the mechanism through which we develop capacity, character, and genuine understanding.

Consider how resentment accumulates: someone speaks with a particular tone, we notice it, build a story around it, feel disrespected, and never address it directly. We carry this small wound until it festers into contempt, eventually forgetting its origin while allowing it to poison every subsequent interaction. Now imagine this process happening constantly—on social media, in politics, in culture—where we absorb the emotional residue of conflicts we’ll never fully understand, building this toxicity into our personalities until it changes us permanently.

This is happening routinely, systemically, and it will not end well unless we begin exploring who we are with ruthless honesty, allowing those insights to ripple through our communities and inspire the compassion, ingenuity, and goodness our world desperately needs.

Today, when you feel that familiar impulse to be kind—and notice the familiar rationalization beginning to form—pause. Take one of those deep breaths that resets your nervous system. And then make the radical choice to behave like the human being you were before the world taught you to be anything else.

Back to blog

Leave a comment