A food essay about Antica Forma Pizza in Moab, Utah by James Bonner

Antica Forma Moab Utah: Culinary Excellence in Neapolitan-Style Pizzas and Italian Delights – A Unique Dining Experience with Warm Ambiance and Sustainable Practices!

Picture your favorite restaurant: maybe there’s a patio shaded by Dogwoods, soft light filtering through leaves, and maybe the walls are lined with paintings, the ceiling hung with potted plants. Or maybe, it’s nothing like that: maybe it’s a squat building off Main Street in Moab, Utah, with Formica tables and a faint motel vibe; maybe it’s Antica Forma.

The name means “the old form,” and it’s not just branding; it’s a philosophy. Inside, the scent of wood-fired dough and San Marzano tomatoes hits you before the décor does—which is good, because the décor isn’t trying to impress. The pizza is. And it does.

Chef Israel Hernandez trained under two of New York’s top pizzaioli, learned Italian out of necessity, and became certified by the Associazione Pizzaiuoli Napoletani. He placed third in the World Caputo Cup, which is basically the Olympics of Neapolitan pizza. When he moved from NYC to Utah, he brought the oven with him—literally. It was flown in from Italy, tiled and temperamental, and it’s the heart of the place.

The menu is a study in restraint. Caputo flour, Belgioioso cheese curd, and tomatoes from the volcanic soil of Mt. Vesuvius. No sugar in the sauce. No shortcuts. The dough is just flour, yeast, and salt. The pizza arrives soft, blistered, and imperfect. It flops. It’s supposed to.

There’s pasta too, house-made, sometimes uneven, always earnest. The wine list is modest but thoughtful. The service is warm in a way that feels familial, not performative. And if you sit long enough, you’ll notice the garden out back, where they grow their own vegetables in season. Even the vanilla in the desserts is made in-house.

Antica Forma doesn’t ask you to be impressed. It asks you to pay attention. To let go of your American pizza expectations—no symmetry, no crust stuffed with cheese—and taste something that’s been shaped by time, fire, and a refusal to compromise.

If you’re in Moab, go. Leave your sensibilities in the car with the window cracked. Order the Margherita. Let the crust flop. And know that sometimes, the old form is the one that still holds.

Back to blog

Leave a comment